Best Places To Find Shrimp In The Hudson Valley

Natalie Brooks

4 min read

Post on May 26, 2025

4.3

Share

Seafood Markets Offering Premium Shrimp

Seafood markets are your best bet for securing the freshest, most flavorful shrimp. These specialized stores prioritize quality and often source their seafood sustainably. Buying shrimp from a reputable seafood market guarantees a superior taste and texture compared to grocery store options.

Top Seafood Market Recommendations:

• Hudson Valley Seafood Co. (Kingston): Known for their commitment to sustainable sourcing, Hudson Valley Seafood Co. boasts a wide selection of shrimp, including wild-caught Gulf shrimp and delectable pink shrimp. They offer a mid-range to high-end price point, depending on the variety.

  • Price Range: Mid-range to High-end
  • Shrimp Types: Wild-caught Gulf shrimp, Pink shrimp, White shrimp, Large shrimp
  • Special Features: Pre-cooked options available, excellent shrimp cocktail

• The Fish Market (Beacon): This family-owned establishment prides itself on its fresh daily catches. They often carry a variety of shrimp, both frozen and fresh, sourced from reputable suppliers.

  • Price Range: Mid-range
  • Shrimp Types: Pink shrimp, White shrimp, occasionally colossal shrimp
  • Special Features: Offers advice on preparation, sells fresh herbs and sauces

• Rhinebeck Seafood (Rhinebeck): A smaller, local favorite, Rhinebeck Seafood focuses on quality over quantity. While their shrimp selection may vary depending on seasonality, they prioritize freshness and excellent customer service.

  • Price Range: Mid-range
  • Shrimp Types: Selection varies, often features locally sourced options when available
  • Special Features: Personalized service, great for questions about preparing shrimp.

Restaurants Serving Delicious Shrimp Dishes

If you prefer the convenience of a restaurant and expertly prepared shrimp dishes, the Hudson Valley offers several excellent choices. From casual eateries to fine dining establishments, you'll find a variety of shrimp dishes to satisfy your cravings.

Top-Rated Restaurants for Shrimp:

• The Mariner's Catch (Beacon): Famous for their spicy shrimp scampi, The Mariner's Catch offers a relaxed ambiance and a menu that celebrates fresh seafood.

  • Price Range: Mid-range
  • Signature Shrimp Dishes: Spicy Shrimp Scampi, Grilled Shrimp Tacos
  • Ambiance: Casual, waterfront views

• The Blue Lobster (Cold Spring): Known for its upscale seafood menu, The Blue Lobster offers a refined dining experience. Their shrimp dishes are a highlight, expertly prepared and beautifully presented.

  • Price Range: High-end
  • Signature Shrimp Dishes: Pan-seared Shrimp with Lemon Butter Sauce, Shrimp Risotto
  • Ambiance: Fine dining, romantic atmosphere

• River Market Bar & Grill (Newburgh): This popular spot offers a more casual setting with a surprisingly sophisticated shrimp selection.

  • Price Range: Mid-range
  • Signature Shrimp Dishes: Shrimp Po' Boy, Coconut Shrimp
  • Ambiance: Lively, casual

Grocery Stores with Reliable Shrimp Options

While grocery stores might not always offer the freshest shrimp compared to dedicated seafood markets, they provide a convenient option for those needing a quick shrimp purchase. Opt for reputable chains with established seafood sections for the best chances of finding acceptable quality.

Grocery Stores for Shrimp Purchases:

• ShopRite: ShopRite stores across the Hudson Valley typically carry a wide variety of frozen shrimp, including various sizes and types, often at competitive prices. They sometimes also have fresh shrimp available, though this is less consistent.

  • Shrimp Varieties: Frozen Pink Shrimp, White Shrimp, Cocktail Shrimp
  • Packaging: Primarily frozen, sometimes fresh
  • Price Range: Budget-friendly

• Wegmans: Wegmans, known for its high-quality products, usually offers a decent selection of shrimp, both fresh and frozen. Check for sustainability certifications on their packaging.

  • Shrimp Varieties: Frozen and fresh shrimp options, depending on location and availability
  • Packaging: Both frozen and fresh options available
  • Price Range: Mid-range

Tips for Choosing and Preparing Fresh Shrimp

Selecting the freshest shrimp is crucial for optimal flavor and texture. Here are some tips to help you make informed choices:

• Appearance: Look for shrimp with firm, translucent flesh and a shiny appearance. Avoid shrimp that are discolored or have a slimy texture.
• Smell: Fresh shrimp should have a mild, sweet, ocean-like smell. A strong fishy or ammonia-like odor indicates spoilage.
• Texture: Fresh shrimp should be firm to the touch; soft or mushy shrimp should be avoided.

Proper Storage: Store fresh shrimp on ice or in the refrigerator immediately. They should be cooked or frozen within 1-2 days of purchase.

Quick Shrimp Recipe: Sauté shrimp with garlic, butter, and white wine for a simple yet delicious meal.

Conclusion: Your Guide to the Best Shrimp in the Hudson Valley

This guide highlights the best places to find shrimp in the Hudson Valley, offering options for every taste and budget. Whether you choose to purchase your shrimp from a specialized seafood market, enjoy a delicious restaurant meal, or opt for the convenience of a grocery store, remember to prioritize freshness and quality. By following our tips for selecting and preparing shrimp, you can ensure a delightful culinary experience. So, go ahead and discover the best places to buy shrimp in the Hudson Valley and savor the freshest, most delicious shrimp the region has to offer! Find the freshest shrimp in the Hudson Valley today!