Paramount+ Users Debate: What's The Best Show?

Natalie Brooks

5 min read

Post on May 27, 2025

4.6

Share

Top Contenders for the Best Paramount+ Show: Drama Category

Paramount+ boasts a strong lineup of dramatic series, attracting viewers with compelling storylines and exceptional acting. Several shows consistently rank highly in discussions about the best show on Paramount+.

"1883": A Prequel Powerhouse

"1883," the highly-acclaimed prequel to the immensely popular "Yellowstone," has quickly become a fan favorite and a serious contender for the best Paramount+ show. Its success is built on a foundation of several key elements:

• Strong acting: The cast delivers powerful performances, bringing depth and emotion to their characters.
• Stunning visuals: The breathtaking landscapes and cinematography are a visual feast, adding another layer of immersion to the narrative.
• Compelling storyline: The journey of the Dutton family westward is fraught with peril and hardship, making for gripping viewing.
• Loyal fanbase: "1883" has garnered a dedicated following who praise its authenticity and emotional resonance. This passionate community frequently debates its place among the top Paramount+ series.

"Mayor of Kingstown": Gritty and Gripping

"Mayor of Kingstown," starring Jeremy Renner, takes a stark and unflinching look at the complex power dynamics within a Michigan city grappling with its prison system. The show's unique premise and intense drama are key to its popularity:

• Excellent acting: Renner leads a talented cast that delivers powerful and nuanced performances.
• Realistic portrayal of a complex world: "Mayor of Kingstown" doesn't shy away from depicting the harsh realities of incarceration and its impact on the community.
• Thought-provoking themes: The series raises important questions about power, justice, and the systemic issues affecting marginalized communities. It's a contender for the best Paramount+ show for those seeking a challenging and impactful viewing experience.

"SEAL Team": High-Octane Action

For fans of high-octane action and military dramas, "SEAL Team" offers a thrilling and realistic portrayal of the lives of Navy SEALs. The show's long run is a testament to its popularity:

• Spectacular action sequences: The show is known for its intense and well-choreographed action scenes.
• Relatable characters: Despite the high-stakes environment, viewers connect with the SEALs on a personal level.
• Strong military themes: "SEAL Team" explores themes of camaraderie, sacrifice, and the challenges faced by military personnel and their families. It frequently appears in "best shows on Paramount+" lists.

Top Contenders for the Best Paramount+ Show: Comedy Category

While drama dominates many "best of" discussions, Paramount+ also houses a strong comedy roster. These shows offer a welcome change of pace from intense dramas.

"The Good Fight": Smart and Hilarious

A spin-off of "The Good Wife," "The Good Fight" blends legal drama with sharp wit and social commentary. Its unique blend earns it a spot in many "best Paramount+ series" conversations.

• Witty dialogue: The writing is sharp, clever, and often laugh-out-loud funny.
• Strong female leads: The show features powerful and complex female characters at its core.
• Topical and relevant themes: "The Good Fight" tackles contemporary social and political issues with intelligence and humor.

"Star Trek: Lower Decks": Animated Comedy Gold

This animated series offers a comedic take on the classic "Star Trek" universe. It's a quirky, funny, and surprisingly insightful show that appeals to both "Star Trek" fans and comedy lovers alike.

• Clever writing: The show is full of witty jokes, pop culture references, and insightful social commentary.
• Relatable characters: The crew of the USS Cerritos are a diverse group of misfits who are easy to connect with.
• Nostalgia factor: For long-time fans of "Star Trek", the show provides a fun and fresh take on the franchise.

Beyond Drama and Comedy: Exploring Other Genres

Paramount+'s expansive catalog extends far beyond drama and comedy. Reality TV enthusiasts will find shows like "The Challenge," known for its intense competitions and dramatic rivalries. For families, there's a wide selection of kids' shows, including many from Nickelodeon's extensive library, offering diverse programming to cater to all ages. This wide array makes it difficult to pick a single "best Paramount+ show" that works for everyone.

The Paramount+ Algorithm and User Preferences

Paramount+'s recommendation algorithm plays a significant role in shaping viewers' experiences. The algorithm suggests shows based on viewing history and preferences, influencing which shows users discover and subsequently consider as "best." Ultimately, though, the "best" Paramount+ show is subjective. User reviews and ratings provide valuable insights, but individual taste remains the ultimate deciding factor.

Conclusion

Determining the single best Paramount+ show is a highly personal endeavor. From the gripping drama of "1883" to the witty humor of "The Good Fight," and the many other excellent shows in between, the platform offers a wide selection. While several contenders frequently top "best Paramount+ series" discussions, the ultimate choice depends on individual preferences. What's your favorite Paramount+ show? Which Paramount+ series do you think deserves the top spot? Join the debate in the comments below and share your thoughts on what constitutes the best Paramount+ show for you! Share your opinions on social media using #BestParamountPlusShow!