The How To Train Your Dragon Remake's Almost Controversial Decision

Natalie Brooks

5 min read

Post on May 13, 2025

4.2

Share

The Justification for the Remake

Why would DreamWorks, a studio already boasting a successful trilogy, choose to embark on a How to Train Your Dragon remake? Several factors likely influenced this decision:

• Modernization of animation techniques: Advances in CGI and animation technology since the original trilogy's release offer the opportunity to create even more breathtaking visuals, enhancing the already stunning landscapes and dragon designs. Imagine the improved detail, the heightened realism, and the overall immersive experience this could deliver.

• Introduction to a new generation of viewers: A new generation of children, who may have missed the original films, now has the chance to discover Hiccup, Toothless, and the captivating world of Berk. The remake presents an opportunity to introduce this beloved story to a whole new audience.

• Potential for updated storytelling and character development: While the original films are lauded for their narrative, a remake allows for subtle refinements to the pacing, dialogue, or even character arcs. This could enhance certain aspects of the story, making it even more engaging and impactful for both newcomers and long-time fans.

• Re-evaluation of the original storyline for improved pacing and narrative structure: While the original trilogy is well-loved, some might argue that minor improvements to pacing or narrative flow could enhance the overall viewing experience.

• Financial implications and potential return on investment: Remakes, when successful, often prove lucrative. The existing fanbase and the proven appeal of the How to Train Your Dragon story provide a relatively low-risk, high-reward scenario for the studio.

Arguments Against the Remake

Despite the potential benefits, the decision to remake How to Train Your Dragon has faced significant opposition. Many long-time fans express deep concerns:

• Concerns about altering a beloved classic and potentially damaging its legacy: The original trilogy holds a special place in many viewers' hearts. Any changes, no matter how minor, risk disrupting the cherished memories associated with the original films.

• Fear of losing the original's charm and unique aesthetic: The original animation style contributed significantly to the films' unique appeal. A significant shift in style could diminish this charm and alienate fans who fell in love with the specific artistic choices of the originals.

• Potential for negative comparisons with the original trilogy: Inevitably, the remake will be judged against its predecessor. Any perceived shortcomings or deviations from the original could lead to harsh criticisms and comparisons.

• The risk of alienating loyal fans and harming the franchise's overall reputation: A poorly executed remake could damage the franchise's reputation and potentially alienate its loyal fanbase. The risk of a negative backlash is substantial.

• Potential backlash on social media and online forums: Online communities dedicated to How to Train Your Dragon are already buzzing with discussions and debates, and the potential for negative sentiment and viral criticism is significant.

Analyzing the "Controversial" Decision

(This section would then delve into a specific controversial aspect of the remake, providing detailed comparisons, analyses, and diverse viewpoints.) For example, if the controversy centers around a redesigned character, this section would provide before-and-after visuals, explore the reasoning behind the design changes, and gather opinions from fans and critics.

The Potential Success (or Failure) of the Remake

The success of the How to Train Your Dragon remake hinges on several key factors:

• Marketing strategy and its impact on public perception: How DreamWorks markets the remake will significantly influence its reception. A successful campaign can manage expectations and build excitement, while a poor one can amplify skepticism.

• Critical reception and reviews: Professional reviews from critics play a significant role in shaping public opinion and can influence box office success.

• Box office performance and financial success: Ultimately, the financial success of the remake will be the key indicator of its overall impact.

• Long-term impact on the How to Train Your Dragon franchise: A successful remake could revitalize the franchise, while a failure could negatively affect future projects.

• Assessment of whether the remake manages to stand on its own while honouring its predecessor: The ideal outcome is a remake that is both a worthy standalone film and a respectful homage to the original trilogy.

Conclusion: The Future of the How to Train Your Dragon Franchise

The decision to remake How to Train Your Dragon is a complex one, with valid arguments on both sides. Understanding the potential benefits – such as introducing the story to a new generation and leveraging modern animation techniques – is crucial, as is acknowledging the significant risks involved, including the potential for alienating loyal fans and harming the franchise's legacy. Whether the remake ultimately succeeds or fails remains to be seen.

What are your thoughts? Do you believe a How to Train Your Dragon remake is a justified move, or a potentially damaging alteration to a beloved classic? Share your opinions in the comments below and let's discuss! Use #HTTYDremake, #HowToTrainYourDragon, and #DreamworksAnimation to join the conversation!